Thank you for using Neighbourly
Here is a message from Bruce Smith, Westland mayor:
Bruce Smith Westland District Mayor. 24-07-2021
On the 3rd of March I published my journey to date with the three Waters reforms being proposed by Government. You can see this summary on youtube.
www.youtube.com...
Now with the 2021 local … View moreHere is a message from Bruce Smith, Westland mayor:
Bruce Smith Westland District Mayor. 24-07-2021
On the 3rd of March I published my journey to date with the three Waters reforms being proposed by Government. You can see this summary on youtube.
www.youtube.com...
Now with the 2021 local government conference behind us where we listened to the Prime Minister and Minister Mahuta and had discussions with a number of Mayors and CEs its time for a further update. Some call it a bribe I prefer incentive.
At the LGNZ conference a 2.5 billion dollar incentive was announced by the Prime minister to encourage councils to opt into the government three water proposals.
Westland District Council was to receive 11 million dollars which we were advised could be used on any project and not refined to three waters. Its stated purpose was to ensure Councils were no worse off after their three waters function and assets were removed by government.
Nothing was mentioned about strings attached by the Prime Minister in her speech.
On the second day of the conference we were informed the money would become available in July of 2024.
It could be spent on projects consulted and approved by IWI and was not confined to three waters investment.
It was subject to councils joining the government masterplan for three waters reform.
This included the transfer of Councils 3 water assets to one of four companies to be established to control the allocation of water, the assets transferred by Councils and the funding of the current and future three water supplies.
It was clarified that Maori would be granted membership and voting rights of 50% of the governance groups that controlled the three water activities and future strategic direction of each of the four entities.
The voting would be 50% Maori and 50% councils who had transferred 100% of the assets to the operating companies.
This government proposal gives Maori who makeup at June 2020 10.4% of the West Coast population and 16.7% of the New Zealand population according to statistics NZ.
Maori in commercial terms gets the right of Veto in perpetuity from government.
This is an unorthodox proposal where 100% of the population have paid for the existing assets and will be paying 100% of all future water costs.
Amongst the conversations it was observed how undemocratic this proposal was. It was noted that the proposal would create a real backlash in our communities. An unintended consequence or is it a further implementation of the HE PUAPUA report.
You can see the report here.
www.nzcpr.com...
The proposed governance structure sits over the operating companies which have no ownership structure as defined in the companies act, have no shareholding and what appears to be an ad hoc distribution of voting rights.
The Mayors were informed by Minister Mahuta that councils have until the end of September 2021 to advise government if they are in or out of the proposed 3 waters reform structure.
Mayors were also informed that information which has not been received at present would be supplied by government via DIA and sent to councils for consideration during August/September.
Councils are required by The Local Government Act to consult with its ratepayers when strategic asset purchases or Disposals are being considered.
I can't speak for other councils but Westland will need at least 3 months upon the receipt of the information to engage experts and receive their advice on the merits and risks of the transfer of assets as proposed by government.
This will then go to ratepayers for consultation and seeking of submissions.
My view is that because of the implications of transferring over a quarter of Councils total assets at below valuation there is only one safe road to take.
I will be advocating for a binding referendum to go out to the people of Westland seeking direction on in or out. It’s called democracy.
It's hard to imagine how any council in New Zealand will be able to make a decision without the clear direction a referendum will bring.
Discussion occurred about what information ratepayers would require to make a decision as at present they are 100% in the dark and will only know what has been read in the media much of which is spin doctor sourced.
The first information required from any ratepayer that has not been in the papers:
what do I pay now?
What will I pay if this proposal is mandated?
I can only talk about Westland.
At present a household pays $527.40 pa water rates.
A commercial business pays $927.12 pa water rates.
If the proposal is mandated households will pay $1,640 to the water supplier for their water.
We have not been told what a commercial user will be charged by the water supplier.
Households need to know if the $1640 is plus GST or inclusive of GST as 99% are not registered for GST.
Another question that ratepayers will need answered is will the $1640 dollars account they received from the water supplier come off my current rates bill?
The answer is a firm NO.
If your WDC household rates are say $3000 at present the $527.40 for water you pay at present will come off your rates from Council.
Your rates will drop to $2472.60 and at the same time you will receive an account from the water supplier for $1,640.
Your cost today is $3,000 which includes water.
Your total cost if the proposal is mandated will be $4,112.60 and that's an increase of 37%.
The mayors talked a lot about democracy and the loss of localism which needs to be considered.
Perhaps we should consider how much influence coasters have with say NZTA.
All Councils have had the NZTA roading contribution this year reduced by a minimum of 10% due to a government directive to put road user charges into rail networks and cycleways.
Health services on the coast now have no direct local input. Its government controlled.
The Tai Poutini Polytechnic now has no direct local input. Its government controlled.
Education is 100% completely controlled from Wellington. Its government controlled.
Social housing is 100% controlled out of Wellington. Its government controlled.
The coast has a serious shortage of social housing and no sign of this being rectified.
Now the proposal is to take all three water assets from the people of Westland, to have them transferred to one of four water supply companies.
There will be no tangible compensation. Households will pay much more for water with no control of future costs.
The government keeps repeating the PR teams key message “ we have proven the case for change”
Government keeps referring to the one event where a failure that occurred in Hastings which had never occurred before or after in New Zealand and is no-where near a justification for change.
There is discussion going on around New Zealand about the removal of control and assets for three waters from councils. Assets which generations of families have paid for with hard earned cash.
What’s proposed seems to fly in the face of our New Zealand democracy and way of life.
I will try and summarise as at 24th of July my journey to date.
The case for change has not been proven.
The water quality bar has been set at a level unaffordable to New Zealanders this is evidenced by the increased cost they will be invoiced by the water regulator to every household.
One size does not fit all.
The loss of local control and influence feels like a step too far.
Confiscation of assets paid for and built up over generations with no compensation will struggle to gain public support.
Some say the proposal to give a right of VETO to Maori who make up 16.7% of the population is undemocratic and will find little support. It follows closely the objectives set out in the HE PUAPUA report
The borrowing of up to 160 billion dollars by the new proposed entities using the assets transferred from our councils and paid for by generations of New Zealanders as security feels reckless.
If its aimed at increasing borrowing in New Zealand away from governments balance sheet it is going to struggle to get support.
The time frames being urgently pursued by government suggest this is not about three waters. If it was why the urgency?
What other councils do around New Zealand is up to them however a public referendum in every district would allow our residents and ratepayers who have along with their families over generations paid for these three water assets and on that basis the decision to opt in or out must come directly from them.
Bruce Smith
Westland District Mayor
021-922860
Hi,
From broken Windows to double glazing ,
I am available for all your glass needs.
Contact Chris on 021642428 for a free measure and quote town or country,
39 years experience proud of my work ,good rates and friendly service
Our friends at Stuff are collating an incredible directory of small businesses delivering during lockdown in every region across New Zealand. Check out the best in baked goods, meal companies, drinks of every sort, groceries and sweet treats delivering right to your neighbourhood.
Supporting … View moreOur friends at Stuff are collating an incredible directory of small businesses delivering during lockdown in every region across New Zealand. Check out the best in baked goods, meal companies, drinks of every sort, groceries and sweet treats delivering right to your neighbourhood.
Supporting local is easy with Support Local, Aotearoa. Have a browse or show your support by submitting a shoutout to a business near you now. They'll thank you for it.
Thanks for supporting local.
Designed for comfort and fun these leggings are super soft & snuggly, with an elastic waistband designed sit comfortably on those precious little tummies.
Several new designs plus more stock of the old favourites!
We are open 9:30 - 1 pm Monday - Saturday until we get to Covid level 2, at … View moreDesigned for comfort and fun these leggings are super soft & snuggly, with an elastic waistband designed sit comfortably on those precious little tummies.
Several new designs plus more stock of the old favourites!
We are open 9:30 - 1 pm Monday - Saturday until we get to Covid level 2, at which time we will revert to our usual hours of 9:30 - 5pm Monday to Friday and 10am - 12:30 pm Saturdays.
If you need anything but can't get out call us on 022 125 1963 or email maryjane@lemontreelane.co.nz and we can deliver in the Stoke area at no charge.
Hi neighbours,
For some weeks now our internet connection has been rather erratic and it seems to be getting worse. We are with MyRepublic.
However, one of our neighbours has said that they are with Vodafone and have been experiencing the same problems for a few months already.
They have … View moreHi neighbours,
For some weeks now our internet connection has been rather erratic and it seems to be getting worse. We are with MyRepublic.
However, one of our neighbours has said that they are with Vodafone and have been experiencing the same problems for a few months already.
They have asked Vodafone for help but nothing has changed.
In the meantime I have started 7(!) chats with MyRepublic, most of which I was cut out before reaching anyone due to the connectivity problems. Shortly after reaching someone I usually was cut out again. Then I always got standard text messages that I "could always try again" to contact them.
One of their reps said ten days ago he would "do a 24hr-line-test" then email me the results on Saturday. Of course, this never happened!
Thus, I changed to emails. So far two, so far no reply.
How is your connection?
What can be done about this, please?
Cheers
Dirk
I am looking for some shelving, display units for a main wall in a lounge dining area. If you know where I could get some or have some or even know a builder or appropriate person who can make some, please let me know. Appreciate your help.
Photo competition time - and one that you can do from your bubble 🙂
Open to all ages and residents of Waimea. Get out your phone, tablet or camera and show us the people, places or parts of Waimea that make you smile.
Email your photos to maree@tsns.org.nz Winning images will be printed for … View morePhoto competition time - and one that you can do from your bubble 🙂
Open to all ages and residents of Waimea. Get out your phone, tablet or camera and show us the people, places or parts of Waimea that make you smile.
Email your photos to maree@tsns.org.nz Winning images will be printed for display in our community later this year.
Our shop is open from 10am - 4pm each day while in Level 3.
If you require contact outside of those hours please call Bev 021 417 509
Most of New Zealand has moved to COVID-19 Alert Level 3. This means we are once again able to repair your computers at our workshop! We can also help you remotely or over the phone. We also stock dozens of laptops and desktops in case you want to replace your computer or get one for remote work or … View moreMost of New Zealand has moved to COVID-19 Alert Level 3. This means we are once again able to repair your computers at our workshop! We can also help you remotely or over the phone. We also stock dozens of laptops and desktops in case you want to replace your computer or get one for remote work or distance learning. During the Level 3, we are offering 20% off our refurbished computers.
A few weeks back I expressed surprise that, on the several prior occasions I'd visited the Saturday Market, I'd seen no sign whatsoever of Nelson's MP. Of course, some of her supporters sought fatuously to challenge my observations with varyingly irrelevances - some like Tim … View moreA few weeks back I expressed surprise that, on the several prior occasions I'd visited the Saturday Market, I'd seen no sign whatsoever of Nelson's MP. Of course, some of her supporters sought fatuously to challenge my observations with varyingly irrelevances - some like Tim Monck-Mason bizarrely accusing me of "moaning," and others like Ngaire Borlase accusing me of "fake news" and waxing lyrical on how quickly Rachel responded to her e-mails ...
Well, as luck would have it, I was e-mailed by a Nelson man who'd read the touted claims of how upfront Rachel was with her answers - but whose own experience in seeking an answer to a simple question had been markedly different. He'd emailed her FIVE times without getting a satisfactory answer. He did receive "flim flam" replies on two occasions from Rachel's assistant, Sarah Kirby - but nothing like a direct answer from Rachel to the simple question he'd posed.
His question: "Was Rachel aware of the He Puapua Report prior to the last election - and if so, did she keep that knowledge from the electorate?" Obviously it required only a "Yes" or "No" - with more detail for a "Yes" - but curiously, Rachel hasn't been in any way forthcoming.
The writer added: "The fact I can't get an answer is in itself the answer. Labour's road map is leading us all to Zimbabwe."
Well as a result, many more of us are now simply busting to know whether Nelson's MP was in fact aware of the abominable He Puapua Report PRIOR TO THE ELECTION - and if she was - EXACTLY WHY SHE MADE NO MENTION OF IT.
Left unanswered, the importance of this may see it elevated to a question in parliament - but I do look forward to input from Rachel's adherents which, in respect of my last post, were so inordinately edifying, 'though somewhat less than uplifting, to a very interested public.
Happy Random Acts of Kindness Day New Zealand 💚
In times like this, it's more important than ever to stay kind and connected. So this year, we ask that you pick up the phone, call someone you care about and check in on their well-being.
It takes a little, not a lot, to be kind and caring … View moreHappy Random Acts of Kindness Day New Zealand 💚
In times like this, it's more important than ever to stay kind and connected. So this year, we ask that you pick up the phone, call someone you care about and check in on their well-being.
It takes a little, not a lot, to be kind and caring 💚
Tomorrow night at 7:30pm Nicky Skinner is doing an online workshop. Message me for the link.
Emotions are at an all time high right now, it can be easy to feel completely overwhelmed and hopeless. Come along to a free hour masterclass to learn some simple and effective strategies to take … View moreTomorrow night at 7:30pm Nicky Skinner is doing an online workshop. Message me for the link.
Emotions are at an all time high right now, it can be easy to feel completely overwhelmed and hopeless. Come along to a free hour masterclass to learn some simple and effective strategies to take control of your stress and anxious feelings and calm your nervous system. You will also learn the basics of essential oils and how powerful they are for our mental health and emotional state.
*OPEN TO THOSE WHO DO NOT HAVE DOTERRA WHOLESALE ACCOUNTS*
looking for old rusty pipe wrenches .picks grubbers spades, shovels ,hedge clippers ,anything i can use to make garden art .Will pick up in level 2
Hi all,
We will be open from 9:30am - 1 pm each day this week if you need any cards, gifts etc.
We can't let you inside the shop but can get anything you want and of course our gorgeous gift wrapping is still available and free as usual!
If you can't get out call us on 5473016 or 022 … View moreHi all,
We will be open from 9:30am - 1 pm each day this week if you need any cards, gifts etc.
We can't let you inside the shop but can get anything you want and of course our gorgeous gift wrapping is still available and free as usual!
If you can't get out call us on 5473016 or 022 1251963 or send an email to maryjane@lemontreelane.co.nz and we can deliver to you within the Stoke area at no charge.
Nelson Tasman Community Transport Trust (NTCTT)
Would you like to help your community?
Would you like to gain new skills?
Would you like to boost your confidence & wellbeing?
We need an experienced Accounts Manager to maintain our financial arrangements, i.e. to make approved … View moreNelson Tasman Community Transport Trust (NTCTT)
Would you like to help your community?
Would you like to gain new skills?
Would you like to boost your confidence & wellbeing?
We need an experienced Accounts Manager to maintain our financial arrangements, i.e. to make approved payments, keep track of funds available for each purpose, fulfil accountability requirements for each grant, make funding applications and prepare and submit annual returns and budgets.
You’ll need to be:
available to attend monthly board meetings,
systematic and thorough,
committed to the cause of providing sustainable transport around the region.
We are supported financially by several funding agencies and wish to maintain and expand this financial base to enable us to do more.
See www.ntctt.org.... Apply to Kate 03 539 0016 / coastalcorridorts@gmail.com
© Neighbourly 2025
Loading…
