41 days ago

The difference between Science & Myth?

Richard from Hutt Central

Some of you may be aware that our Royal Society (of scientists) is currently investigating and looking to censure (perhaps worse?) one of its distinguished own for making written statements that are at variance with the current narrative that insists Mātauranga Maori should stand, in curricula, equally and alongside what the modern world in general otherwise acknowledges as 'Science'. This, in recent years, has polarised those in our universities and (given other co-signatories to the one above and some notable recent resignations), also those within the Royal Society of NZ.

The issue has now hit the world stage with the likes of Jordan Peterson making comment, and now the more readily recognisable scientist, Richard Dawkins, has entered the fray. Here's the latter's recent thoughts on the issue. I'll leave you to make you own inquiries and draw your own conclusions as to whether this is befitting our national science community, and the science curricula for our younger minds we should be seeking to build and maintain.

Dr Roger Ridley
Royal Society of New Zealand

Dear Dr Ridley

I have read Jerry Coyne’s long, detailed and fair-minded critique of the ludicrous move to incorporate Maori “ways of knowing” into science curricula in New Zealand, and the frankly appalling failure of the Royal Society of New Zealand to stand up for science – which is, after all, what your Society exists to do.

The world is full of thousands of creation myths and other colourful legends, any of which might be taught alongside Maori myths. Why choose Maori myths? For no better reason than that Maoris arrived in New Zealand a few centuries before Europeans. That would be a good reason to teach Maori mythology in anthropology classes. Arguably there’s even better reason for Australian schools to teach the myths of their indigenous peoples, who arrived tens of thousands of years before Europeans. Or for British schools to teach Celtic myths. Or Anglo-Saxon myths. But no indigenous myths from anywhere in the world, no matter how poetic or hauntingly beautiful, belong in science classes. Science classes are emphatically not the right place to teach scientific falsehoods alongside true science. Creationism is still bollocks even it is indigenous bollocks.

The Royal Society of New Zealand, like the Royal Society of which I have the honour to be a Fellow, is supposed to stand for science. Not “Western” science, not “European” science, not “White” science, not “Colonialist” science. Just science. Science is science is science, and it doesn’t matter who does it, or where, or what “tradition” they may have been brought up in. True science is evidence-based not tradition-based; it incorporates safeguards such as peer review, repeated experimental testing of hypotheses, double-blind trials, instruments to supplement and validate fallible senses etc. True science works: lands spacecraft on comets, develops vaccines against plagues, predicts eclipses to the nearest second, reconstructs the lives of extinct species such as the tragically destroyed Moas.

If New Zealand’s Royal Society won’t stand up for true science in your country who will? What else is the Society for? What else is the rationale for its existence?

Yours very sincerely
Richard Dawkins FRS
Emeritus Professor of the Public Understanding of Science
University of Oxford

More messages from your neighbours
2 hours ago

What's On: Rebus Club of Petone

Graham from Hutt Central

Retired, looking for fun, friendship, interesting speakers and outings. Meetings held 4th Wednesday of the month. Visitors welcome. Call Caryl 045604676 or Graham 045692914. Double vaccination required. Next meeting,
Rebus Club of Petone
  • Petone Central Bowling Club rooms
11 hours ago

Bike Mechanic Wanted

Beverley from Hutt Central

Two Ladies Bikes needing basic repairs please call 04 939 9939
Qualified or experienced bike mechanic needed!

1 day ago

Sign up for The Antidote: 5 happy things to read about each day

The Team Reporter from Stuff

Hi neighbours,

We live in unusual times. It all gets a bit much some days. So we're bringing you a much-needed dose of positivity to remind you that there's inspiration, kindness and quirkiness out there too.

You can check out today's edition of The Antidote - which features a cute puppy, the UK's longest-married couple, and Stewart Island's "savage" New Year's Eve here. If you'd like the Antidote delivered direct to your inbox, sign up here.